Updated October 2026
CO-4 means the procedure code does not agree with the modifier used, or a modifier the payer requires is missing. CO means contractual obligation. The amount is generally not billable to the patient, but check your contract and state rules before billing a patient.
Common causes of CO-4
- A required modifier was left off, such as 25, 59, 26, TC or a laterality modifier
- A modifier was added that the code does not allow
- The wrong modifier was chosen for the situation
- Payer-specific modifier rules that differ from your billing system's defaults
How to fix CO-4
- Read the remark code and the payer's modifier policy for that procedure
- Check the note to see which modifier, if any, the documentation supports
- Correct the modifier and resubmit as a corrected claim
- If a needed modifier was truly omitted, add it and send documentation if asked
How to prevent CO-4
- Keep a modifier checklist by specialty
- Turn on modifier edits in your claim scrubber
- Train coders on payer-specific differences
Related denial codes
- CO-97: Included in the payment for another service
- CO-11: Diagnosis does not match the procedure
- CO-16: Claim lacks information or has an error
- All denial codes
For how to read group codes, reason codes and remark codes together, see claim denial codes explained. The official code list is maintained by X12.
Working denials like this is what our denial management service does. To see where your own denials come from, request a free billing audit.
Frequently asked questions
Where do I find the remark code for CO-4?
On the electronic remittance advice (ERA 835) or the paper explanation of benefits, next to the adjustment. The remark code (RARC) often names exactly what is missing or wrong.
Which modifiers cause CO-4 most often?
Modifiers 25 and 59 and the professional and technical component modifiers 26 and TC are common causes. See modifiers 25 and 59.
Does the wording of this code change?
Yes. The code list is maintained by the standards organization X12 and updated regularly, and payers may use a code slightly differently. Always read the remark code and the payer's policy.
